Are you looking for a simple way to make your Healthfirst premium payment without the hassle of logging in online or sending mail? Paying by phone might be your best option! I’ve gathered all the info you need to easily pay your Healthfirst bill by phone, plus some alternative payment methods if you prefer something different
The Easiest Way to Pay Your Healthfirst Bill by Phone
Healthfirst makes it super easy to pay your monthly premium by phone Their Member Services team is ready to help with your payment needs, but you’ll need to call the specific number for your plan type
What You’ll Need Before Calling:
- Your account number or marketplace ID
- A bank account, credit card, or debit card for payment
- A few minutes of your time
Phone Numbers by Plan Type:
Here are the specific numbers to call based on your Healthfirst plan
Healthfirst Child Health Plus
- Call: 1-866-463-6743
- TTY: 1-888-542-3821
- Hours: Monday to Friday, 8am–6pm
Healthfirst Leaf Plans
- Call: 1-888-250-2220
- TTY: 1-888-542-3821
- Hours: Monday to Friday, 8am–8pm
Healthfirst CompleteCare (HMO SNP)
- Call: 1-888-260-1010
- TTY: 1-888-542-3821
- Hours: 7 days a week, 8am–8pm
Healthfirst Medicare Advantage Plans
- Signature (HMO) Plan: 1-855-771-1081
- Signature (PPO) Plan: 1-833-350-2910
- All other Medicare Plans: 1-888-260-1010
- TTY: 1-888-542-3821
- Fax: 1-646-313-4618
- Hours: 8am-8pm, 7 days a week (October-March) and 8am-8pm Monday-Friday (April-September)
Senior Health Partners
- Call: 1-866-585-9280
- TTY: 1-888-542-3821
- Hours: Monday to Friday, 8am–8pm, and Saturday 10am–6pm
The Phone Payment Process
When you call, the process is pretty straightforward:
- Dial the appropriate number for your plan
- Have your account number or marketplace ID ready
- Tell the representative you want to make a payment
- Provide your payment information (bank account or card details)
- Confirm the payment amount
- Get a confirmation number (write this down!)
I personally find this method super convenient when I’m on the go and don’t have time to log into the website. The representatives are usually friendly and efficient, making the whole process take just a few minutes.
Other Ways to Pay Your Healthfirst Bill
While paying by phone is convenient, Healthfirst offers several other payment methods too:
1. Paying Online
This is probably the quickest method if you’re comfortable with technology. You can use a credit card, debit card, or checking account to pay online.
For New Members:
- Make your first payment to activate your new plan
- Visit the Healthfirst website and select “Make Your First Payment”
For Existing Members:
- Log in to your secure Healthfirst account
- Choose the “Log in” option on the payments page
- Follow the prompts to complete your payment
Remember that you must pay each invoice or transaction ID separately, and you’ll need your Account Number or marketplace ID handy.
2. Paying By Mail
If you prefer the traditional route, you can mail your payment via check or money order. Just remember to:
- Write your account number or Marketplace ID on your check/money order
- Make it payable to “Healthfirst PHSP”
- Send it to the correct address for your plan type
Mailing Addresses by Plan:
Healthfirst Child Health Plus
HealthfirstP.O. Box 48242Newark, NJ 07101-4842
Healthfirst Leaf Plans
Healthfirst Leaf PlansP.O. Box 95000-5645Philadelphia, PA 19195-5645
Healthfirst CompleteCare (HMO SNP)
Healthfirst CompleteCareP.O. Box 95000-5170Philadelphia, PA 19195-5645
Healthfirst Medicare Advantage Plans
Healthfirst Medicare PlansP.O. Box 48243Newark, NJ 07101-4843
Healthfirst Signature (PPO)
Healthfirst Insurance Company, Inc.Healthfirst Signature (PPO)LB 8418P.O. Box 95000Philadelphia, PA 19195-0001
Senior Health Partners
Senior Health PartnersP.O. Box 48344Newark, NJ 07101-48344
Tips for Hassle-Free Healthfirst Bill Payments
After helping my parents with their Healthfirst payments for years, I’ve picked up some useful tips:
-
Set calendar reminders – Setting up a monthly reminder on your phone can prevent late payments.
-
Keep your account info handy – Store your account number somewhere secure but accessible so you don’t have to hunt for it every month.
-
Check payment processing times – Phone payments process quickly, but mail payments need several business days.
-
Ask about autopay options – If available, autopay can eliminate the monthly task completely.
-
Save confirmation numbers – Always write down or save confirmation numbers from phone payments in case there’s any question later.
-
Call during off-peak hours – Try calling early in the morning to avoid longer wait times.
Comparing Payment Methods for Healthfirst Bills
| Payment Method | Pros | Cons | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|
| Phone | Immediate, personal assistance, confirmation provided | Limited to call center hours | People who prefer speaking to a representative |
| Online | 24/7 availability, fastest method | Requires internet access | Tech-savvy members |
| No electronic payment needed | Slowest method, no immediate confirmation | People who prefer traditional payments |
Frequently Asked Questions About Paying Healthfirst Bills by Phone
Can I make a partial payment by phone?
You’ll need to discuss this with the Member Services representative. Typically, Healthfirst expects full premium payments, but they may be able to work with you on payment arrangements.
Is there a fee for paying by phone?
Healthfirst doesn’t typically charge fees for phone payments, but your bank or credit card might apply fees depending on your account terms.
What if I don’t have my account number handy?
The representative can usually look up your account using your name, address, and sometimes your date of birth or social security number.
Can someone else call and pay my bill for me?
Yes! A family member or authorized person can make a payment on your behalf, but they’ll need your account information.
What payment methods are accepted for phone payments?
You can use credit cards, debit cards, or electronic checks (using your bank routing and account numbers).
What if I call outside of business hours?
You’ll likely reach an automated system that can’t process payments. It’s best to call during the specific hours listed for your plan type.
How do I know my payment went through?
Always ask for and write down your confirmation number. This proves you made the payment in case there’s any confusion later.
Alternative Payment Options: Beyond Healthfirst
If you’re exploring additional payment methods, some members have found success with these options:
Google Pay
Google Pay offers a convenient way to manage payments across devices. While not directly mentioned as a Healthfirst payment method, many financial institutions are compatible with Google Pay’s systems. This service offers:
- Tap-to-pay functionality in stores
- Simple online checkout with saved payment details
- Enhanced security with built-in authentication
- Encrypted transactions to protect your financial information
Health First Online Payments
Note that Health First (separate from Healthfirst) also offers online bill payment options through their MyChart system. Don’t confuse the two services! Health First is a healthcare system primarily in Florida, while Healthfirst is a health insurance provider primarily in New York.
What to Do If You’re Having Payment Issues
If you’re struggling to make your Healthfirst premium payments, don’t worry! Here are some steps that might help:
-
Contact Member Services – Call the same phone numbers used for payments and ask about hardship programs or payment plans.
-
Check for subsidy eligibility – You might qualify for additional financial assistance with your premiums.
-
Explore switching plans – If your current plan is too expensive, Healthfirst offers various options at different price points.
-
Ask about grace periods – Most health insurance plans offer grace periods before cancellation for non-payment.
Wrapping Up: The Simplest Way to Pay Your Healthfirst Bill
Paying your Healthfirst bill by phone is one of the easiest and most direct methods available. With dedicated phone lines for each plan type and representatives ready to assist, you can complete your payment in minutes.
Remember to have your account information and payment method ready before calling, and always get a confirmation number for your records.
Whether you choose to pay by phone, online, or mail, Healthfirst offers flexible options to ensure you can maintain your health coverage without interruption.
Have you tried paying your Healthfirst bill by phone? What was your experience like? We’d love to hear your tips and tricks in the comments below!

What Is The Healthfirst OTC Payment Website?
The HealthFirst OTC payment website is the official platform where members can pay bills, manage their accounts, and review transactions. Visit the website link provided on your billing statement or card to access this service. Here is the link: https://healthfirst.org/payments
Can I Pay My Healthfirst OTC Bill By Phone?
Yes, you can pay your HealthFirst OTC bill by phone.
- Call the customer service number provided on your billing statement or card.
- Follow the prompts to provide your payment details securely
- Confirm the transaction with the representative or automated system.