Ever been slapped with a ridiculously high medical bill that made your heart skip a beat? You’re not alone. The healthcare system in America is designed to make you feel helpless, but guess what? You don’t have to accept it.
As a healthcare consumer advocate, I’ve seen firsthand how people get taken advantage of by our predatory healthcare system. That’s why I was thrilled to discover Marshall Allen’s groundbreaking book, “Never Pay the First Bill: And Other Ways to Fight the Health Care System and Win.”
The Healthcare System is Rigged (But You Can Fight Back!)
Let’s be real – the American healthcare industry makes RECORD profits every year while regular folks like us get less and less for our money They’ve created this super complex system on purpose to make us feel confused and discouraged from taking action.
The truth? We can push back and WIN.
Marshall Allen, an award-winning ProPublica reporter and Pulitzer Prize finalist, spent 15 years investigating the healthcare industry. His book is basically the guerrilla warfare guide that American consumers and employers desperately need.
Why You Should Never Pay That First Bill
The title of Allen’s book is actually brilliant advice: Never pay the first bill. But why?
Simply put, medical bills are frequently wrong. Like, REALLY frequently. Billing errors, upcoding (charging for more expensive services than you received), duplicate charges, and outright price gouging are standard practice.
When you get that first bill, here’s what you should do instead
- Analyze it carefully – Look for errors, duplicate charges, or services you didn’t receive
- Request itemized billing – Hospitals and providers often send summary bills with minimal detail
- Contest anything suspicious – You have the right to challenge charges
- Negotiate – Even legitimate charges can often be reduced
Practical Strategies to Fight Back and Win
Allen’s book offers a practical battle plan. I’ve tried several of these strategies myself with great success:
1. Get Billing Codes in Advance
Before undergoing any procedure or treatment, ask for the billing codes (CPT codes) they’ll use. This gives you:
- Transparency about what you’re being charged for
- The ability to compare prices between providers
- Documentation if they try to charge for something different later
2. Add a Treatment Clause Before Signing
Before signing financial documents, write in a clause like:
“I consent to appropriate treatment and reasonable costs, but I do not agree to pay excessive charges far above the going rate.”
This simple addition gives you legal protection and leverage for later negotiations.
3. Small Claims Court Is Your Friend
If all else fails, small claims court is surprisingly accessible and doesn’t require a lawyer. Many healthcare providers will settle rather than show up to court.
A buddy of mine took this approach with a $2,800 ER bill that should’ve been covered by insurance. The hospital settled for $400 rather than face him in court!
4. Use Cash Prices to Your Advantage
Many providers offer significant discounts for cash payments. Even if you have insurance, sometimes the cash price is LOWER than your co-pay or what you’d pay toward your deductible.
Always ask: “What’s your cash price for this procedure?”
Real Victory Stories from People Who Fought Back
Allen’s book shares numerous success stories of regular people who refused to be victims:
- A teacher who saved $1,200 on a surprise medical bill by requesting itemized charges and identifying errors
- A small business owner who reduced a $40,000 hospital bill to $7,000 through persistent negotiation
- A retiree who avoided paying $25,000 for a procedure by comparing prices and finding a provider who charged $6,000 for the exact same service
For Employers: You Have Power Too
If you’re a business owner or HR professional, you have even more leverage:
- Request transparency in pricing from insurance providers
- Consider self-funding health plans with strong oversight
- Implement medical bill review services for employees
- Educate your team on how to spot and fight billing errors
The Bigger Picture: Why We Need to Fight
This isn’t just about saving a few bucks. Every time we push back against predatory healthcare practices, we’re:
- Protecting ourselves and our families financially
- Sending a message that consumers won’t be taken advantage of
- Contributing to systemic change in healthcare pricing and billing
As Allen puts it in his book, “Few politicians and CEOs have been willing to stand up to the medical industry. It is up to the American people to equip ourselves to fight back for the sake of our families—and everyone else.”
My Personal Experience
Last year, I received a $3,500 bill for a simple outpatient procedure that should’ve cost around $800. Using techniques from Allen’s book:
- I requested an itemized bill
- I identified three services I never received
- I compared prices with other local providers
- I wrote a detailed dispute letter
The result? My bill was reduced to $950. Still not cheap, but WAY better than $3,500!
Key Takeaways from “Never Pay the First Bill”
If you want to arm yourself against healthcare price gouging, remember these core principles:
- Be skeptical of every medical bill you receive
- Document everything – calls, names, dates, what was promised
- Know your rights as a patient and consumer
- Be persistent – the system counts on you giving up
- Use public pressure when needed – social media can be powerful
Resources to Help You Win
Beyond Allen’s excellent book, here are some tools to help your fight:
- Healthcare Bluebook – Compare fair prices for procedures
- FAIR Health Consumer – Look up typical costs in your area
- Patient advocacy groups in your state
- Sample dispute letter templates
The Bottom Line: You Have More Power Than You Think
The health care industry wants you to feel helpless. They’ve designed a complex system specifically to discourage you from fighting back.
But Marshall Allen’s “Never Pay the First Bill” shows that with the right knowledge and tactics, ordinary people can successfully challenge unfair bills and win against a predatory system.
As Allen says on his website, “We can take back control of our health care. When we do, we make things better for ourselves, our families and one another.”
So next time you get that shocking medical bill in the mail, remember: never pay the first bill. Analyze it, contest it, and use the strategies outlined here to fight for what’s fair. The system may be broken, but you don’t have to be its victim.
Have you successfully fought a medical bill? What tactics worked for you? Share your experiences in the comments below!
Additional Resources
Want to learn more about fighting unfair medical bills? Check out these resources:
- Order Marshall Allen’s book “Never Pay the First Bill” from Penguin Random House
- Visit Marshall Allen’s website for more resources and victory stories
- Sign up for Allen’s newsletter for ongoing tips and support
Remember, the healthcare system may seem intimidating, but armed with knowledge and determination, you CAN fight back and win!
Random Acts of MedicineAnupam B. JenaPaperback$100
101 Things I Learned® in Psychology SchoolTim BonoHardcover$199
Never Pay The First Bill – Fight the Healthcare System and Win
FAQ
What is never pay the first bill?
Never Pay the First Bill is the guerilla guide to health care the American people and employers need. Drawing on 15 years of investigating the health care industry, reporter Marshall Allen shows how companies and individuals have managed to force medical providers to play fair, and shows how you can, too.
Does the health care industry have a new ‘never pay the first bill’?
Nearly three decades later, ProPublica investigative health care reporter Marshall Allen, author of the new book “Never Pay the First Bill (and Other Ways to Fight the Health Care System and Win)” says things haven’t improved. He’s been covering the industry for 15 years.
Are You struggling to pay medical bills?
But then the bills come – hundreds, maybe thousands, maybe hundreds of thousands of dollars. So many Americans are struggling to pay medical bills – unexpected debt that for some leads to financial ruin. Marshall Allen is an investigative reporter, and he’s been digging through medical bills for years.
Should we pay the first medical bill?
But I argue that we should never pay the first bill until we have checked it to make sure it’s accurately priced and accurately documented. When you talk to experts who review medical bills for a living, they will tell you that almost every medical bill has some kind of an error.
What should consumers do if a bill is incorrect?
You write that Crystal Paulson, a nurse and patient advocate, recommends eleven steps consumers should take to fight back against incorrect bills [see below], with Step One being to request an itemized bill. Why do you get itemized receipts at the grocery store but it’s not mandatory that hospitals send them out? It should be required.
Will my insurance company pay my bill if I have an error?
So, even if you have an error in your bill, your insurance company will just pay it. You really get this feeling that you’re on your own. And I think that’s the sense of betrayal that the American public feels.
