Prior to the distribution of an estate by an executor to its beneficiaries, an executor must prepare an accounting which outlines the assets of an estate, its liabilities, and the expenses paid by an estate prior to actual distributions being made. In the vast majority of estates, the accounting that is prepared is called an “informal accounting”, as a formal accounting is an accounting that is filed with the county surrogate and audited by the county surrogate. Nonetheless, this informal accounting should provide a detailed outline as to how the estate was administered by the executor. The question posed by this blog, however, is what are your rights as a beneficiary of an estate if you believe that there is an error, or something is amiss with the accounting?
There are essentially two paths that you can follow as a beneficiary with the possibility that the paths might converge at some point in the future. The first path is to request that the executor prepare a formal accounting that will be audited by the county surrogate. This can be accomplished by requesting that the executor file such an accounting, or you might decide to file a lawsuit to compel a formal accounting. The negative to this path, however, is that both the attorney for the executor, as well as the county surrogate will be paid by the estate during this process which will reduce the corpus of the estate. Further, this process could greatly lengthen the time before distributions can be made by the estate. The other option would be to review the informal accounting produced by the executor and to raise any objections with the executor which will be discussed during this blog.
In general, the informal accounting must first provide a detailed inventory of all assets of the estate, whether financial assets, real property, or personal property. This inventory should provide accounts statements, or appraisals as of the date of death of the decedent in order to give an accurate value of the estate at the time that the decedent passed away. Next, the accounting should provide a detailed summary as to all liabilities, or expenses of the estate. These liabilities and expenses should be accurately categorized on a spreadsheet with totals which evidence the total amount of expenses paid by the executor on behalf of the estate. Upon request, the executor should be prepared to provide all account statements upon which the inventory was founded, as well as all receipts, bills, or invoices which evidence the expenses and liabilities of the estate. Hopefully, the informal accounting will accurately and correctly depict the estate’s assets and all necessary and appropriate expenses. If so, then in that event, the beneficiaries can seek their appropriate distributions according to the decedent’s Will. Should issues arise with the informal accounting, however, there are two potential paths going forward.
The first path that a party should pursue if there are issues with the informal accounting is to attempt to obtain clarification from the executor concerning any issues regardless of their nature. During such process, the executor should review the issue with the beneficiary, and further, should be able to provide all relevant back and documentation which helps to clarify the estate’s position. If the explanation is acceptable, then the issue can be resolved. On the other hand, if there appears to be problems with the executor’s explanation, or the back-up that was provided, the beneficiary should engage in discussions with the executor to attempt to resolve the dispute by way of a compromise, or by the executor amending the accounting to reflect a necessary change. The vast majority of disputes between an executor and beneficiary are resolved informally, as it tends to make sense for all parties, as compared to the final option which would involve the commencement of a lawsuit. Simply put, the time and money that will be involved in a lawsuit typically does not make sense unless the issues with the informal accounting are substantial in monetary value. Otherwise, the costs of litigation will exceed any potential recovery. On the other hand, should a beneficiary discover a substantial issue for which the executor cannot offer a reasonable explanation, nor does the executor wish to compromise, litigation may be the only alternative. That process will be discussed in another blog.
DISCLAIMER: Because of the generality of this update, the information provided herein may not be applicable in all situations and should not be acted upon without specific legal advice based on particular situations. Attorney Advertising.
Being a beneficiary of an estate can be complicated especially when you suspect the executor isn’t being completely honest. As a beneficiary, you have rights to ensure the executor is fulfilling their fiduciary duties. In this comprehensive guide I’ll walk you through the process of auditing an executor to protect your inheritance.
What is an Executor’s Fiduciary Duty?
An executor (sometimes called an executrix if female) has a legal obligation to administer the estate according to the best interests of all beneficiaries. This fiduciary duty includes:
- Keeping accurate records of all estate transactions
- Providing regular updates to beneficiaries
- Filing necessary tax returns
- Making sound decisions that benefit the estate
- Distributing assets according to the will
Unfortunately, not every executor acts with complete transparency or honesty Sometimes, executors may prioritize their own interests over those of other beneficiaries, delay distributions unnecessarily, or even misappropriate assets.
Warning Signs That May Warrant an Audit
Before launching into a full audit watch for these red flags that might indicate executor misconduct
- Lack of communication or transparency
- Unexplained delays in estate settlement
- Refusal to provide financial information when requested
- Suspicious transactions or missing assets
- The executor seems to be living beyond their means
- Discrepancies in reported asset values
- Excessive fees or expenses charged to the estate
Your Legal Rights as a Beneficiary
As a beneficiary, you have legal rights to information about the estate. The most powerful tool in your arsenal is requesting a formal accounting.
Formal Estate Accounting
A formal estate accounting is a detailed financial disclosure that forces the executor to itemize every transaction related to the estate. The accounting typically includes:
- A complete inventory of all estate assets
- All income received by the estate
- All disbursements and expenses paid
- Details of investments made
- Information about debts paid
- Planned distributions to beneficiaries
In New Jersey and many other states, an executor can’t be compelled to provide a formal accounting until at least one year after being appointed, unless special circumstances exist.
Steps to Audit an Executor
If you’re concerned about an executor’s actions, follow these steps to conduct an audit:
1. Request an Informal Accounting First
Before pursuing formal legal action, request an informal accounting from the executor. Send a written request asking for:
- A list of all estate assets
- Bank statements
- Investment account statements
- Records of all transactions
- Explanation of fees charged
Sometimes, this simple request can resolve issues without further conflict.
2. Review the Will Carefully
Understand what the will actually says about:
- The distribution plan
- Powers granted to the executor
- Any specific instructions for handling assets
- Timeframes for distributions
3. File for a Formal Accounting
If the executor refuses to provide information or if the informal accounting raises more questions, you can petition the court for a formal accounting. This is a legal proceeding that forces the executor to provide a comprehensive accounting of all estate activities.
After the executor files the formal accounting, beneficiaries can challenge specific portions through “exceptions.” For example:
- If the executor claims $1,000 was spent on something that doesn’t benefit the estate (like Caribbean airfare), you can file an exception requiring justification.
- If assets are missing from the accounting, you can file an “omission” to have the account corrected.
4. Hire Professional Help
Consider hiring these professionals to assist with your audit:
- Estate attorney: Can help navigate the legal process and file court petitions
- Forensic accountant: Can review financial records to identify discrepancies or mismanagement
- Financial expert: Can compile and analyze estate information
5. Look for Specific Issues
When auditing an executor, be on the lookout for:
- Missing or incomplete documentation: All transactions should have supporting documentation
- Unusually high expenses: Watch for excessive fees or questionable expenses
- Unaccounted-for assets: Compare the inventory with what you know existed
- Self-dealing: The executor shouldn’t be making transactions that benefit themselves
- Conflicts of interest: Watch for relationships with service providers that might indicate kickbacks
6. Take Legal Action if Necessary
If your audit uncovers serious issues, you may need to:
- File a petition to remove the executor
- Request the court to surcharge the executor for misappropriated funds
- Seek damages for breach of fiduciary duty
What to Expect During the Audit Process
The audit process can take time – often months. It can also be costly, as the estate typically pays for financial experts to compile information. Before pursuing a formal accounting, weigh the potential benefits against these drawbacks.
Some beneficiaries may be intimidated by the process. Remember that executors are required to provide this information – it’s not an unreasonable request. In fact, many states require executors to provide an accounting to beneficiaries before an estate can be closed.
Receipts and Releases
In most probate cases, executors prepare an informal accounting for beneficiaries along with a “receipt and release” document. When you sign this document, you’re confirming that you’ve received the accounting and releasing the executor from future liability.
Be cautious about signing such documents if you have unresolved concerns. Not all states allow executors to condition your receipt of an accounting or property on signing a release.
Final Thoughts
Auditing an executor isn’t about creating conflict – it’s about ensuring transparency and protecting your rightful inheritance. Many problems can be resolved through open communication, but when that fails, knowing your legal rights and the audit process is essential.
If you’re dealing with an uncooperative executor, consider consulting with an estate attorney who specializes in probate litigation. They can guide you through the specific requirements in your state and help you determine the most appropriate course of action.
Remember that as a beneficiary, you have a right to know how the estate is being handled. An honest executor should have nothing to hide and should willingly provide the information you request.
Have you dealt with auditing an executor? What challenges did you face? Share your experiences in the comments below!
Disclaimer: This article provides general information and should not be considered legal advice. Laws regarding executor duties and beneficiary rights vary by state. Always consult with a qualified attorney for advice specific to your situation.
What do you want from legal thought leadership?
Please take our short survey – your perspective helps to shape how firms create relevant, useful content that addresses your needs:
If I Agree To Act As An Executor How Will I Know What To Do? | @GuyDiMartinoLaw
FAQ
Does an executor need an estate accounting?
Executors are required to keep beneficiaries reasonably informed about the status of estate administration — a duty which generally includes accounting. For this reason, if an executor is doing their job, it usually won’t be necessary for beneficiaries to request an estate accounting.
How does a probate executor prepare an accounting?
In most probate cases, the Executor will prepare an informal accounting for the beneficiaries. Along with the informal accounting (which could be as simple as an Excel spreadsheet), the Executor may include a receipt and release document.
Do executors have a duty to provide accurate estate accountings?
Executors have a duty to provide accurate estate accountings. If accountings are inaccurate or misleading in any way, the beneficiaries are entitled to challenge them in court. The likely outcome of such a dispute would be for the court to order the executor to correct the accountings.
Does an executor have to show accounting to beneficiaries?
Grasping the answer to does an executor have to show accounting to beneficiaries is essential for both executors and beneficiaries involved in estate matters. Executors are legally bound to maintain complete transparency and fairness, ensuring beneficiaries receive clear, accurate financial information throughout the probate process.
What do executors need to know before closing an estate?
Before the executor can finalize probate and close the estate, they must provide a final accounting that includes: Beneficiaries have the right to review the accounting. They also have the right to request more information. If they want to see supporting documentation, the executor must provide things like:
Do executors have to file a formal accounting?
An Executor who finds that the beneficiaries are suspicious of him, despite no wrongdoing, is free to voluntarily file a formal accounting to prove that the books are in order and the proposed distributions are correct. Either way, a formal accounting is a unique, self-contained action in the chancery court.
How do you hold an executor accountable?
- Requesting an accounting of the executor’s financial actions taken on behalf of the estate, including the assets collected, debts and expenses paid, and inheritances already distributed.
- Pursuing mediation to resolve disputes between beneficiaries and the executor.
Does an executor have to show accounting to beneficiaries after?
While it isn’t generally required for the executor to provide receipts and other supporting documentation of estate-related transactions to beneficiaries, it …Jan 5, 2025
How do you know if the executor of a will is being honest?
They swear an oath when they get probate. If you suspect the executor of dishonesty, apply to the court, or the probate registry, for an order to provide information about the assets and liabilities of the estate.
What mistakes does an executor make?
- Lacking a specific goal or objective in mind. …
- Not educating yourself on the probate process. …
- Delaying the initiation of the probate process for too long. …
- Not promptly and appropriately securing and safeguarding the assets of an estate.
